Overview
Go to Paragraph 1
Guénon begins this chapter by examining the phenomenon of Western encroachment upon the rest of the world. He observes that the modern West does not merely differ from other civilisations; it actively seeks to absorb or destroy them. This is not a matter of legitimate influence but of a disordered expansion driven by the very nature of the modern spirit itself.
He argues that the West’s claim to bring civilisation to other peoples is a pretext. What the West actually brings is the destruction of traditional social structures, the imposition of its own materialistic values, and the reduction of all cultures to a uniform mediocrity. The so-called mission civilisatrice is nothing but a rationalisation of greed and the will to power.
Guénon then examines the various forms that this encroachment takes. Colonisation is the most obvious, but it is not the only one. Economic penetration, the spread of Western education, the imposition of European languages, and the dissemination of Western ideas through journalism and publishing—all these are instruments of the same encroachment. They work together to undermine traditional civilisations from within, creating a Westernised elite that serves as a relay for further domination.
He notes that the Westernised elite of the East is a particularly tragic phenomenon. These men have cut themselves off from their own traditions without truly assimilating the West’s spiritual heritage (which, in any case, the modern West no longer possesses). They are left with nothing but a superficial veneer of Western manners and a contempt for their own people. They become, in effect, the most zealous agents of Western encroachment.
The chapter then turns to the question of resistance. Guénon observes that many in the East have reacted against Western domination, but their resistance is often compromised by the very terms in which it is conceived. Some seek to imitate Western methods of organisation, believing that this will allow them to compete on equal terms. Others attempt to create a synthesis between East and West, hoping to preserve what is best in both. Guénon dismisses both approaches as illusory. To imitate the West is to accept its fundamental premises. To attempt a synthesis is to assume that two incompatible principles can be reconciled.
He insists that authentic resistance must be based on a return to the traditional principles of the East itself. This does not mean a simple conservatism that clings to outward forms while the inner spirit has departed. It means a reawakening of true intellectuality, a recovery of the metaphysical knowledge that the West has lost. Only such a recovery can provide a foundation for a civilisation that is truly independent and truly itself.
Guénon then discusses the attitude that Westerners who are sympathetic to the East should adopt. He warns against a false Orientalism that collects exotic curiosities while remaining fundamentally Western. The Westerner who wishes to help the East must first overcome his own Western prejudices. He must recognise that the East has nothing to learn from the West in spiritual matters, and very little even in material matters except what is strictly useful. The proper role of such a Westerner is to work for the restoration of his own civilisation, not to pose as a guide to the East.
The chapter also addresses the objection that the East is itself decadent and therefore cannot claim superiority over the West. Guénon concedes that the East has suffered a long decline, as all civilisations do in the Kali-Yuga. But he distinguishes between decadence and deviation. The East is decadent in the sense that its traditional forms have weakened over time. But it has not deviated from its principles. The West, by contrast, is not merely decadent but deviated: it has actively rejected the principles that give civilisation its meaning. A decadent civilisation can be restored by returning to its principles. A deviated civilisation, cut off from its principles, has no such hope.
He concludes that the present crisis offers an opportunity. The destruction wrought by Western encroachment may clear the ground for a genuine renewal. The very violence of the modern assault may provoke a reaction strong enough to sweep away the accumulated impurities that have weakened the traditional civilisations of the East. But this will happen only if those who still possess authentic knowledge do their work, preparing the elements that will survive the coming catastrophe.